Sep 17, 2007

He actually voted to be adult baptized before he was infant baptized

The latest John McCain flip-flopping story finds him distancing himself from the Episcopal church. (And wouldn't you, if you were trying to establish your social conservative bona fides right now? Which reminds me--while I disagree with McCain on any number of issues, I think it's unfair the way religious conservatives won't give him the time of day. Apparently McCain-Feingold--which was intended to restrict all sorts of "issue ads," not just the anti-abortion ones--and a years-old shot at Falwell and Robertson are enough to make people ignore the fact that the senator's actual voting record on abortion is mighty similar to Sam Brownback's.)

Anyway--McCain claimed yesterday to be Baptist, despite his Episcopal heritage and the fact that he's never joined the Baptist church at which he worships. This actually makes a certain amount of sense to me, as I suspect it does to many (though certainly not all) Protestants. I was dedicated as an infant in a Baptist church and raised and baptized in a nondenominational church with no formal membership rolls (and a relatively low view of baptism). At present I work at an Episcopal church at which I'm also deeply invested as a parishioner, but I remain a member of a Lutheran church halfway across the country--though I was never formally received into the denomination.

When people ask me about my denominational affiliation, my answer varies with the context of the question. Still, that's a bit different from an answer that varies based on what a given group of people want to hear. Backpedaling today, McCain said that "the most important thing is that I am a Christian." I don't know John, that sounds pretty broadly inclusive, pretty un-culture-war-ish, pretty Episcopalian...

2 comments:

  1. i don't think it's weird that he's not hung up on claiming membership in one particular denomination, but the fact that his staff says, "we put episcopalian because that's what we've always put on these forms" probably shows that he's generally not made faith a political priority.

    ReplyDelete